HID Lights Showdown: Philips Xtreme Vision vs Osram CBB

Philips and Osram HID bulbs lined up for shootout comparison

This week we are putting the best of the best from Philips head to head, and then we are pitting the top performer against the reigning champion from Osram. Last week we ran through the full Osram lineup and crowned the CBB as the king of the hill for raw intensity. Today we do the same kind of shootout with Philips, and then we stage das shootout between our two friends from Germany, Philips and Osram. If you want to know which of these hid lights actually puts the most usable light on the road, we lit every one of them up on the same bench so you can see the numbers for yourself.

How We Tested These HID Bulbs

Consistency is everything when you are comparing lux output, so we controlled every variable we could. Every bulb was powered by the same Morimoto XP 35 watt ballast, and every reading came from the same spot in the beam pattern projected by a Morimoto Mini D2S 4.0 Bi-Xenon projector. We also gave each bulb a 30 second warm-up before taking any measurement, because HID output changes during the first minute of operation. That means the differences you see below come from the bulbs themselves, not from mismatched hardware or timing.

Morimoto XP35W ballast powering all bulbs for a fair comparison

We pulled four bulbs off the shelf for this one. From Philips we grabbed the 85122 standard, the Xtreme Vision Gen2, and the White Vision Gen2. Then we grabbed the Osram CBB, which was our clear winner last week in terms of intensity. If you want the deeper dive on where these stack up against the rest of the field, we also put together our full D2S bulb comparison guide that covers Morimoto, Philips, and the Osram CBI side by side.

Philips 85122 Standard: The Industry Benchmark

We started with the Philips 85122 standard D2S, the classic old school bulb that most people have seen whether they know it or not. This is the bulb you will commonly find as original equipment across a huge range of applications, including Toyota, Lexus, Audi, and Mercedes. It is rated by Philips at 4300K and has been the benchmark in the retrofitting and lighting world for as long as we can remember.

Philips 85122 standard HID bulb, the industry benchmark

On the bench the 85122 put out a nice, even light with a warm lean to it, which is great for all weather visibility. After the 30 second warm-up it measured 250 lux right in the middle of the beam pattern. That is a clean, round baseline number and exactly what we expect from the reference bulb that every other option gets measured against.

Philips Xtreme Vision Gen2: The Brightest of the Bunch

Next up was the Philips 85122 Xtreme Vision Gen2, the newer version of what many enthusiasts consider the gold standard for Philips output. Philips rates these at 4800K, so they are slightly whiter than the standard bulb, and they were originally released as an answer to Osram when the CBI first arrived on the scene.

Xtreme Vision Gen2 lighting up the beam pattern

When we lit it up and checked the same position in the beam, the meter read 444 lux. That is considerably brighter than the 250 lux from the standard 85122, nearly double the output. Looking at it with our own eyes, the Xtreme Vision Gen2 is visually a little whiter than the standard bulb, but it still carries a slight hint of yellow. It is not as white as something like a CBI, and that is not a knock, it is just a characteristic.

Here is something worth keeping in mind. Warmer colored light penetrates through particles in the air more effectively than white light, which tends to reflect off of fog, rain, and snow. So if you live somewhere that snows a ton, rains constantly, or fogs up often, a warmer bulb like the Xtreme Vision Gen2 actually works in your favor. The slight yellow tint is not a flaw, it is a feature for bad weather regions.

Philips White Vision Gen2: The Whitest Philips Option

The third Philips bulb was the White Vision Gen2, the newer version of their whitest offering. This one is a bit of a mystery because Philips has not published an official color temperature for it. However, Philips tends to follow the industry standard wire color convention running from brown to white to blue. Given that the standard bulb is 4300K and the mid-tier sits around 5000K, our best estimate puts the White Vision Gen2 just under 6000K. That should give you even more white light than the other two Philips options.

On the meter, the White Vision Gen2 came in at 320 lux. That is a respectable number, certainly less than the Xtreme Vision Gen2, but still a nice bump in both whiteness and output over the standard bulb. For anyone who has already decided to go with a Philips bulb and wants the whitest output currently on the market from them, the White Vision Gen2 is the answer. It landed very close to what we saw from the Osram CBI in last week’s test, which came in around 340 lux, so there is not much difference there.

Osram CBB: The Reigning Intensity Champion

Finally we brought in the Osram CBB, last week’s winner for intensity. We were temporarily out of stock on the D2S version, so we used the D1S instead. That is not a problem for this comparison, because the D1S and D2S share the exact same capsule and the same burner. The only difference is the ignition hardware, and since the ballast is what determines power output, we simply swapped the D2S igniter for a D1S cable and powered it with the same Morimoto XP 35 watt ballast. The results are equal to what we would see from a D2S. This was also the mercury-full version, not the mercury-free version.

Osram CBB bulb glowing with neutral white output

The moment it fired up, the difference in color was obvious. The CBB is definitely whiter than any of the Philips options, clearly a higher Kelvin rating regardless of what the manufacturers print on the box. It was the whitest of the entire bunch, carrying a neutral white tone with even a slight tinge of blue. For anyone chasing that clean neutral white look, the CBB delivers it over any current Philips option. If you want to grab a set for a D1S equipped car, these are the same Osram Cool Blue Intense D1S HID bulbs family we work with regularly.

On the meter, the CBB read 421 lux, and when we checked it again it held steady at 420 lux. That is an excellent result and sits right near the top of the field, just a hair below the Xtreme Vision Gen2.

The Final Numbers: All Four Bulbs Compared

Let us line them all up. The Philips 85122 standard measured 250 lux at 4300K. The White Vision Gen2 measured 320 lux at an estimated just under 6000K. The Osram CBB measured 420 to 421 lux as the whitest bulb in the test. And the Philips Xtreme Vision Gen2 measured 444 lux at 4800K, taking the top spot for raw output.

Lux meter showing HID bulb brightness comparison results
Final lux readings comparing all four HID bulbs

Going into this, we were confident the CBB would take the crown for intensity, because we are honestly Osram kind of people. But the Xtreme Vision Gen2 edged it out at 444 lux versus the CBB’s 420 to 421 lux, making it not just the brightest Philips bulb in this test but the brightest bulb on our shelves overall.

Which HID Bulb Should You Buy?

The choice really comes down to what you value most. If you want a higher Kelvin rating, something in the neutral white range with no off-white color but nothing too crazy blue or icy, and you want the brightest white option available, the Osram CBB is undoubtedly the way to go. It is the best choice these days for that combination of clean color and strong output.

If you want the most light output overall and you do not care about color, or if you want something a little warmer for the weather reasons we mentioned earlier, go with the Philips Xtreme Vision Gen2. It is the brightest bulb in this entire test and a genuinely practical pick for anyone who regularly drives in fog, rain, or snow. Either way, you really cannot lose with these two at the top.

If you are shopping around and want to see how Morimoto’s own capsules stack up in the same class, take a look at the Morimoto XB D2S HID bulb lineup before you make a final call. There is always something new around the corner, so there is a good chance we will be back next year running another one of these shootouts.

Frequently Asked Questions

Which Philips HID bulb is the brightest in this test?

The Philips Xtreme Vision Gen2 85122 measured 444 lux, making it the brightest bulb in the entire shootout, including the Osram CBB.

How does the Osram CBB compare to the Philips Xtreme Vision Gen2?

The Osram CBB measured around 420 to 421 lux, slightly below the Xtreme Vision Gen2’s 444 lux, but it produced the whitest light with a slight blue tinge.

What color temperature is the Philips White Vision Gen2 rated at?

Philips has not published an official rating, but based on the industry standard wire color pattern the host estimates it falls just under 6000K, higher than the 4300K standard and 4800K Xtreme Vision Gen2.

Can a D1S bulb be used to fairly compare against D2S bulbs?

Yes, since the D1S and D2S share the same capsule and burner, the host used a D1S cable with the same Morimoto XP 35 watt ballast to get equivalent results for the Osram CBB.

Why would someone choose a warmer HID bulb over a whiter one?

Warm colored light penetrates fog, rain, and snow more effectively than white light, which tends to reflect off particles in the air, making warmer bulbs like the Xtreme Vision Gen2 useful in bad weather regions.


Meet the Experts Behind The Retrofit Source

Tyler Jordan, Technical Writer at The Retrofit Source

Tyler Jordan – Technical Writer
Tyler works directly with the TRS product R&D team, bringing over a decade of automotive aftermarket lighting experience to every article. An avid enthusiast with hundreds of personal installations under his belt, his content is built on hands-on knowledge from the workbench, not spec sheets.

Caleb Morgan, Marketing Manager at The Retrofit Source

Caleb Morgan – Marketing Manager
Caleb brings over a decade of automotive lighting industry experience and works with TRS customers daily on the front lines. With hundreds of personal lighting installations and a direct feedback loop from real buyers, his content addresses the questions and problems that actually matter.